# Independent import follow-up review

**Verdict: no remaining actionable issues found.**

Reviewed exact committed diff `d6a057f9f..9cbe27cf3` in `/home/stevan/dev/compass-verify-imports`, read only. No application files were edited and no additional agents were dispatched.

Scope covered the extraction attempt counter and migration, manual retry/enqueue failure races, stale worker success/error/exhaustion writes, legacy one-argument jobs, attachment touches, preview edit/confirm locking, empty and non-importing replace-all selections, transaction rollback after model validation failures, and the new shared row normalization/duplicate validation.

The dedicated counter remains stable across attachment metadata touches. Retries increment it under the upload lock. Workers check the supplied attempt both before extraction and after reloading under that lock; exhaustion and terminal error writes use the same predicate. Missing legacy attempt arguments resolve to attempt zero, so they cannot overwrite later attempts. Queue failures update only their own still-pending attempt. The additive default-zero/non-null migration is consistent with that compatibility behavior.

Confirmation rejects pending/failed/completed or superseded uploads. The apply service refuses an empty valid selection before any deletion, including replace-all submissions whose selected actions cannot import. Removing the row-level RecordInvalid rescue lets the enclosing savepoint roll back both earlier row changes and replace-all deletions. The ordinary browser's replace-all toggle already disables per-row conflict actions, so its behavior remains consistent with the service's import defaults.

Evidence: source/call-chain review plus inspection of the added request, service, and worker regressions. The owner reported 327 focused examples with zero failures (seed 17370), and 14 linted files with no offenses; this reviewer did not independently rerun those tests. The parent owns integrated suite and browser verification.